Dear reader

Dear reader
Dear reader
Dear reader

Do you always trust what you read? We don’t…

Welcome to the Spring edition of GreymatterFinch’s newsletter, sharing our perspectives from the world of reporting. Building on our previous newsletter’s theme of ‘change’, this edition focuses on ‘trust’.

In a world of change, people desire certainty and trust

We live in a world with increasing lines of defence (it started with three, then five and now moving beyond seven it seems) aimed at checking, rechecking and assuring against error and misstatement.

How does a stakeholder know that a company is spending money wisely? That they are making sound investments and share their values? Unfortunately, trust is not always the first word people think of when it comes to corporate reporting. Stakeholders are wary of empty commitments and obligatory, compliance-driven disclosures.

Definition

Greenwashing is defined as unsubstantiated or misleading claims about an entity’s environmental performance or selective disclosure or non-disclosure about the environmental or social impacts of a company’s business practices.

dailyinvestor.com

‘Whoever is careless with the truth in
small matters cannot be trusted
with important matters’

– Albert Einstein

The consequences of untrustworthy reporting can be dire. When a business publishes a report to influence the decision-making of stakeholders – be it an integrated annual report, a sustainability report or a governance report – and does so not providing evidence, but made-up or exaggerated claims, it is misleading its audience. And when this happens in corporate reports, it can be considered fraud.

Investors have been questioning the trust they can place in companies’ reporting when it comes to environmental, social and governance (ESG) matters. Greenwashing is being called out, and whistleblowing is becoming more prevalent.

Effective communication is the art of securing trust at scale

Effective communication is the art of securing trust at scale
Effective communication is the art of securing trust at scale
Effective communication is the art of securing trust at scale
  • Earlier this year, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced the formation of a Climate and ESG Enforcement Task Force to proactively identify ESG-related misconduct. One of its objectives is to identify any material gaps or misstatements in issuers’ disclosure of climate risks under existing rules.
  • In May, the SEC charged BNY Mellon, an investment adviser, for making misleading statements about the ESG investment considerations of its managed mutual funds. This resulted in the SEC issuing a cease-and-desist order and a penalty of $1.5 million (R25.9 million) against BNY Mellon.
  • Also at the end of May, prosecutors in Frankfurt raided the offices of both Deutsche Bank and its asset management subsidiary DWS as part of an investigation into the greenwashing of investment products.
  • In 2019, a derivative suit was filed in the United States by ExxonMobil’s shareholders against its directors for a breach of fiduciary duty and failure to disclose the impacts of climate change on the company’s business reserves and assets.

We are likely to see more greenwashing claims as public attention on climate change continues to grow and sustainability becomes increasingly important in consumer and investor decision-making.

Against this backdrop, the corporate world will need to ensure that ESG-related claims are unambiguous, accurate and supported by objective evidence, and that public statements on decarbonisation commitments are backed up by action.Radical transparency in the challenges and opportunities related to ESG commitments is key to build trust, forge fruitful stakeholder connections and develop business models that work. Clear, transparent communication can help create certainty and trust for investors, employees, customers, and local communities.

How we help clients to create transparent, impactful reports

GreymatterFinch’s advisory team works with clients to develop content for their reports.

We invest time to build robust local and international research, knowledge and expertise in the latest corporate reporting requirements. Clients leverage this experience to ensure their reports transparently meet stakeholders’ information needs.

We are objective and independent. By anticipating the tough questions, we draw out material information.

Our multi-disciplinary teams – from project management to design and digital – then work with the advisory team to package information in ways that external stakeholders can easily understand.

An update on momentum toward a simpler reporting system for non-financial performance

In June, after a period of public comment, the JSE released its final Sustainability Disclosure Guidance and Climate Change Disclosure Guidance, which aligns to global best practice while acknowledging the importance of our South African context.

At the International Cooperation Forum and Meeting of African Ministers of Finance Economy and the Environment in Egypt in September, African Ministers and other representatives of international bodies expressed support for the work of the IFRS Foundation’s International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB).

News in focus

News in focus
News in focus
News in focus

Daily Investor: South African financial sector faces litigation risks if ESG matters are ignored

Role players are proactively engaging with institutional investors and asset managers on integrating ESG factors into their decision-making and are facing increasing scrutiny of their investment activities. Webber Wentzel warned participants in the South African financial sector to ensure that disclosures on ESG matters are accurate, well-founded and backed up with data to avoid greenwashing litigation.

EY and Oxford Analytica: The emerging sustainability information ecosystem

A recent report from EY and Oxford Analytica outlines steps companies can take to optimise their ESG reporting. The report highlights five areas of improvement to bring ESG reporting up to speed with financial reporting, as they warn that growing allegations of greenwashing risk eroding credibility.

BCG.com: From compliance to courage in ESG

Companies that use ESG initiatives as an exercise in compliance, rather than a source of competitive advantage, are leaving substantial value on the table. To truly unlock the competitive advantage that comes from being a leader on ESG topics, it’s not enough to track KPIs and publish reports. It’s about creating congruence between the commitments that the company is making to the world and the decisions being made inside its walls.

EY.com: 7 ways CFOs can drive the sustainability agenda

Increasingly, CFOs find themselves at the centre of the sustainability agenda. CFOs have always been responsible for managing financial value and reporting to key stakeholders. But today, those key stakeholders are demanding more than short-term profitability from organisations. They’re questioning how much of a company’s value is reflected in its financial reports alone, and are looking at the triple bottom line, which recognises value generation in terms of people, planet and profit.

Our most read articles on LinkedIn

Our most read articles on LinkedIn
Our most read articles on LinkedIn
Our most read articles on LinkedIn